Both brands offer outstanding wind protection, with Dynasty shingles being the better value for its lower labor charges because it doesnt require the enhanced (time-consuming) installation. California has established 16 climate zones based on representative weather and temperature data. You can imagine that its not easy to recreate Mother Natures beauty of genuine wood or natural slate. Achieving that look in an asphalt shingle requires subtle color changes or gradations, a deep dimensional profile or depth and very specific cuts. Perhaps in 5 years when the new SBS sealant used on shingles sold in cool climates has a proven track record, that will change. Think good value for the contractor a product they can sell at a higher margin. The IKO Homeowners choose 3-tab shingles for their affordability. Strips of tacky sealant help to adhere the shingle. Founder of Roofing Business School. It is the basic job of any roof shingle to withstand the damage and force of strong winds, especially if the home is located in a particularly stormy region. The Best Value Architectural Shingle: Tie. To ensure complete satisfaction you should make final color selections from several full size shingles and view a sample of the product installed on a home. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited. Tamko vs GAF: Which Roof Shingle Brand Is Better? Strength denotes flexibility and resistance to tearing, stretching, as well as loss in strength due to exposure to elements. Two such brands that we will be putting head to head in this showdown are IKO and GAF. Put 35 squares on a 2,000 square foot ranch home, and youll pay about $210-$350 more for the shingles. It is the decision theyve made to make a better more premium shingle, though at a higher cost than IKO, Atlas, Owens Corning, GAF, and Tamko. Using its color-blending technology to vary the shades of each tab in a particular color blend, IKO has achieved an amazing level of depth for an asphalt shingle of monolayer or single-layer construction. . Becausetraditional 3-tab shinglesare the most basic type to manufacture and the lightest to install, theyre also among the most cost-effective. Take advantage of the innovative services at Roofing Insights to search for quick, professional, and reliable care from a team of knowledgeable contractors you can trust. Atlas Roofing vs. IKO Shingles Costs Comparison (1) The retail cost per square can be lower with bulk discounts for popular fiberglass shingles like IKO Cambridge, Cambridge Cool Colors and Dynasty shingles and Atlas GlassMaster and Pinnacle Pristine shingles. In the photo below weve highlighted the impact locations where hail has damaged a standard shingle roof. Pro Tip: Heres what we said in our IKO Shingle Review with Pros and Cons, Because IKO might have ongoing problems with sealing, it is a risk to install them unless the air temperature is at least 50F with clear, sunny skies. Where sealing isnt an issue with IKO shingles in warm climates, and even in cool regions when IKO shingles are installed in warm weather, the brands are equal in quality. The standard wind rating for 3-tab shingles is 60 MPH, though a few have 80 MPH warranties. Grey or neutral siding or stone; white trim. This is just one great reason why IKO Cambridge remains among our most popular shingles with homeowners and contractors alike. Where Atlas offers a price, advantage is in the top-of-the-line and very popular StormMaster Shake and Slate lines at about $120 per square. We should also mention that Atlas, like many other manufacturers including CertainTeed, GAF, Owens Corning and IKO, has been the subject of a class action lawsuit. Quality Roofing Services. On the other hand, if you have your heart set on a higher-end look or a specific color combination, the IKO Dynasty line might better suit your preferences. IKO LIMITED WARRANTY | Information for Asphalt . His articles offer practical advice and expert insights that help readers tackle their home improvement projects with confidence. High winds are a major threat to blowing them off. Wondering which to choose . Stone, wood, brick, siding (especially white or various pastels). Traditional three-tab shingles, including Alaskan, Dura-Seal 20 and Dura-Seal 25. By this metric, we find that both IKO and GAF shingles are mostly comparable across all of their product lines, being rated Class F (the highest rating) on the ASTM D3161 standard. Some of ourIKO Dynasty with ArmourZone shingles are definitely not for the faint of heart! Built-in blue-green algae resistance will help keep them looking their best. There is no additional charge to you! to get the information you were looking for! Its designed to mimic the impact of large hail and wind-blown debris. Comparing CertainTeed and IKO asphalt roofing shingles will give you a number of excellent options when the time comes to repair or replace an existing roof, or select a roof for a new home. In this head-to-head, we find that the warranty on GAF shingles is a lot more favourable for most homeowners. IKO strives to accurately reproduce the screen images of the shingle swatches and house photos shown. Log, beige stone or brick facings; brown trim. These shingles stand out for the varied width of the tabs/teeth, which many homeowners think provides a more genuine slate look. With an SRI (Solar Reflectance Index) of 20 or higher based on color, they meet some of the countrys local cool roof requirements such as California Title 24 (more on this topic later). This means that the roof and the home its protecting stay cooler than a comparable building roofed with traditional shingles. IKO Cambridge Cool Colors are not available in Canada or all geographic areas of the U.S.A. and color selection may vary by region. listed below. Lets explore. Shingles from both GAF and IKO have all been found to pass the Class A rating under the UL 790 standard for roof heat and fire resistance. Available in up to 15 colors where you live, Dynasty shingles include the ArmourZone construction a larger fortified nailing area. Classic or contemporary elegance. The main difference is that IKO Royal Estate shingles are designed with a random-cut profile rather than a uniformly square one. IKO Nordic shingles with ArmourZone are the perfect choice if you want your new roof to harmonize well with your homes natural surroundings. These extraordinary color blends go above and beyond. The two architectural shingles by IKO are called Cambridge and Cambridge Cool Colors. We've got you covered if you're looking for the best roofing companies in Cape Coral, Florida. Here's a strategy for discussing the rising costs, Roofers have a bad habit of not listening to their, Monday motivation: ALL YOU NEED is a phone to crea, @mattrisinger of @risingerbuild gives an insider l, We have featured a lot of pro-solar opinions on Ro, Why you NEED to be thorough in your own inspection, In this video, Dmitry shares five things you need, Insurance claims vs. Other major metro areas like Dallas/Fort Worth, and Chicagoland have roofing costs that are close to the national average. Looking for the highest-rated roofing companies in Port Charlotte, Florida? No expensive, specialized contractors needed. The Trusted Solution to a Beautiful Roof. Most shingles are three bundles per square (each bundle containing around 33 square feet), but thicker shingles are sold in smaller bundles, so you need 4, 5 or more for the same 100 square foot coverage. Thanks to their larger-than-average size, these designer laminated architectural shingles go down fast, to help minimize installation time, labor and cost. Thanks to our exclusive, advanced color blending technology, IKO Cambridge architectural roofing shingles are available. IKO Cambridge Cool Colors asphalt shinglescan be used to meet the reflectivity requirements of 2016 Title 24 Part 6 Cool Roof Requirements to improve your homes energy efficiency and potentially help reduce its carbon footprint and cooling costs while elevating its curb appeal. Shingles wont seal unless they warm to an ambient temperature near 70 degrees. IKO 3-Tab shingles cost approximately $2 to $4 per square foot installed. However, due to manufacturing variances, the limitations of your monitor resolution and the variation in natural exterior lighting, actual colors may vary from the images you see. Its a 1-1/4-inch nailing surface thats reinforced by a tear-resistant, woven band that provides more fastening strength over a wider surface area of the shingle. All rights reserved. Cost differs, too: The average cost per square of the IKO shingles is $6-$10 per square more compared to Atlas. We recommend the best products through an independent review process, and advertisers do not influence our picks. Earthy, organic, rustic, laidback, casual. The choice is yours. We give a slight advantage to Atlas for lower overall pricing in the core lines. But note: It is the bundle price that is usually displayed at the store or online, though some sites do the math for you and give you the per square price, or price of enough bundles to cover 100 square feet of your roof. All at a comfortably affordable price. For further details concerning the FM 4473 standards, visit the FM Approvals website. Selection varies by geographic region. And a contractor wont quote you a bundle price on IKO (remember, IKO doesnt sell directly to the public). Weight/100 sq. Plastic and rubber shingles are also considered composites, but theyre usually shaped like tiles. Whether you want your new roof to blend in or stand out among your home's . Or are you a roofing contractor and thinking about trying. You wont have the worries of regular maintenance, fire or termite damage often associated with real wood (which may be prohibited by local building codes in your area). Feel its weight. Our high-quality roofing shingles provide superior weather protection and boost the curb appeal of homes throughout the United States and Canada as well as many export markets. Secondly, because if the re-roofing job is a tear off, meaning it already has two layers on it and all the roofing material must be removed down to the wood roof deck, youll need more materials and labor. Ensure your roof is properly vented, since a buildup of heat and moisture in the attic is a major cause of shingle failure. Small Kitchen, Big Transformation: Turning a Cramped Space into a Cozy Haven, Defiants Smart Lock Deadbolt Offers Keyless Entry at a Fraction of the Cost, Top 4 Best Pest Control Companies (2023 Review), 8 Best Cheap Window Replacement Companies (2023 Savings Guide), How To Find Help Covering Moving Expenses, Todays Homeowner Radio Show Podcast | April 29, 2023, Todays Homeowner Radio Show Podcast | April 22, 2023, Todays Homeowner Radio Show Podcast | April 15, 2023, Ask Danny | Ep. any homes style, from traditional to modern, rustic to urban. IKO uses an exclusive, advanced color blending technology for some of the most stunning looks and effects available. This color blend shows how closely these luxury shingles resemble genuine cedar shakes. Bensuaves . 2High Wind Application is required. IKO Armourshake is much more expensive than anything Atlas sells, but its also a very different product. Cost Advantage: Slight Advantage for IKO. Looking for the best residential or commercial roofing companies in Fort Myers, Florida? IKO wins because its Cambridge Cool Colors shingles are offered in 4 colors with demonstrable SRI ratings that is, they reflect solar/UV enough to meet some Cool Roof (CRRC) requirements. The key to its wind-resisting prowess is the fortified ArmourZone core nailing area that optimizes protection against wind uplift and the penetration of wind-blown rain. The disadvantage of 3-tab shingles is their thinner, and therefore weaker, construction. Get back to beautiful basics with IKO Marathon Plus AR. Price varies by line, but neither has a clear advantage in value. These terms might describe a shingles look, what its made of or even what its function is. #IKOroofshingle #architecturalshingles #bestroofingshinglesAre you wanting to start your own roofing company, in the process of starting one, or your roofing company isnt giving you the results that you were expecting? The warranty can be transferred once within the first 10 years. White or grey siding, stone or brick; white or grey trim. But most start at about $75 per square, or a very affordable 75 cents per square foot. While the battle for contractors and homeowners attention and residential roofing marketshare between Atlas and IKO shingles doesnt have the same heavyweight interest of GAF vs. Owens Corning, these brands are certainly not fighting over scraps. Note: Please make your final color selection from several full size shingles and view a sample of the product installed on a home. IKO Cambridge architectural shingles can enhance. Malarkey has been a family-owned company in Portland, Oregon, since 1956. Here are two sets of costs. So, how are the benefits and drawbacks of each shingle line quantified? Digital Roofing Innovations has launched our AWARD WINNING immersive course How to Start a Roofing Company: How to Work Less, with Less Stress, and Make More Money!. But many of the other shingles are higher in price than the competition. Take that New Roof Back to Beautiful Basics. When we called around to wholesalers remember, IKO doesnt sell direct to the public most did not stock Armourshake. Retrieve your username. High-profile laminate shingles, including Legacy, NorthwestXL, and Highlander CS. By staggering the size and position of the shingles dragons teeth, were able to create a random, varied pattern that emulates the rich textured appearance of genuine wood shakes. By and large, IKO shingles are only sold to roofing contractors who then pass on their costs to the homeowners. According to the IKO warranty, you must use 3 of these products to receive the top 130 MPH wind warranty. (2) Installed cost includes materials and supplies, building permits, site cleanup, professional installation, and workmanship warranty. Damage from hail is not covered under the limited warranty. This imparts superior weather resistance, even in extreme cold. The accessories include StormShield Ice & Water protection, Stormtite underlayment, Leading Edge Plus starter strips/shingles and UltraHP ridge cap shingles. However, there are plenty of other solid and compelling shingle options to consider outside of the mid-range lines, including the affordable 3-tab shingles, several high-end architectural series, and premium shingles from both brands. It is our choice for the best value in a high-performance shingle from either IKO or Atlas. How are they different? Stone, wood, brick, masonry, siding (especially cream, beige or grey). IKO Armourshake in Shadow Black. Here are some tips onhow to choose the right shingle color. IKO Dynasty with ArmourZone shingles help resist nail pull-through even at high winds and carry a 210 km/h (130 mph) limited wind warranty 1 with the use of only four nails.