On average, Orijen guarantees about 15.39% more protein than Kirkland Signature. The probiotic, BC30, supports your pets immune system, provides improved nutrient absorption, reduces gas and improves stool quality, and prevents the growth of yeast organisms that may cause skin problems and ear infections.. Ingredient Analysis: The first five ingredients are chicken, turkey, flounder, mackerel, and turkey giblets which give this food a protein-packed, nutrient-dense foundation. All of these ingredients offer highly bio-available nutrients meaning the body does not have to work as hard to retrieve the nutrients. Review: 91% of the over 2,000 reviews give this food a 4 or 5-star rating, with some buyers saying this is the next best thing to freeze-dried raw food. Dry dog food has also proven to have some dental benefits for dogs who are prone to plaque buildup as to the crunchy nature of the food can assist in keeping teeth healthy. From Orijen regular formula (dark blue bag) to a Kirkland brand food. Besides animal-based food, youll also find nutritious vegetables, fruits, and other plant-based products such as: And to boot, the ingredients are organic and selected from quality sources. While you can find Orijen in some retail stores, it isnt super common like Hills, for example, making those emergency purchases quite difficult. It is suitable for adult dogs and is sold in various sizes. Q: Should I let my dog eat food containing chicken or fish meal? The thing to remember is that dogs are not wolves; they need a balanced diet containing: It is true that a dogs digestive tract is designed for meat, but they have evolved to live alongside humans. Some criticism of this method has been shown to include risks of food-borne illnesses of consuming raw meat. 14.8M views. There is a relatively insignificant difference between the crude fiber content of the two brands. 83. Zignature tops our best dog food list as one of the most recommended dry dog food brands. They were impressed with the quality and consistency of the kibble and praised it for its nutrient density while remaining grain-free. A: Yes, some dog breeds are more energetic than others, and therefore there are specific dog food brands that cater for certain dog breeds. Orijen Dog Food offers a wide specter of recipes. Review: Most ratings of this product are highly complementary. This leads to what is also required, a Guaranteed Analysis, on each label. We are compensated for referring customers. They both exist to give your dog some real food that has all the essential nutrients for their bodies. As we previously stated, having your dogs main food available in stores can be a huge help if you need it fast. Orijen might be on the more expensive end. All food fed to your pet should have a balance of mostly protein, followed by fats, a small amount of carbohydrates, along with essential vitamins and minerals. During our nutrient analysis, we found Crafted Kibble to have an excellent breakdown. Total Microorganisms* not less than 1,000,000 CFU/lb (Lactobacillus acidophilus, Bifidobacterium animalis, Lactobacillus reuteri) *Not recognized as an essential nutrient by the AAFCO Dog Food . The elephant in the room is the drastic difference in meat content; there is a debate on how much meat dogs really need in general. They will send a custom-sized package of meals out every 14 days; simply toss them in your refrigerator or freezer and feed one package per day. Here are some of the controversial ingredients used only by Kirkland Signature. This is due in large part because of the high volume of meat that goes into each bag, and the absence of unnecessary fillers or grains that have been known to cause problems for some dogs. Thank you for shopping with our retail partners! , are made in Morinville, Alberta, Canada. While Orijin recipes have a meat content of 85 to 90%, all of which are fresh, Acanas recipes contain 50-75% of meat, which is significantly less. Although it is a very inexpensive ingredient, it is not nutritionally empty. Summary: This kibble is formulated to be easy for small breed dogs to chew and digest. ACANA is manufactured in the United States and is a tiny bit cheaper, while Orijen is manufactured in Canada and is slightly more expensive. This brand is directly compared to Orijen very often and is highly regarded as one of the best. Ingredient Analysis: Chicken, turkey, flounder, and whole mackerel are the first ingredients that ensure this food has a high protein content. 0.3%. is to remain grain-free or use healthy ancient grains. It's mostly about the convenience. As a result, many individuals believe that whole prey diets are the best-balanced diet to feed a canine. Use this table to filter for the best-reviewed or use the search bar to filter the best dog food brands by rating. However, I do continue to purchase the smaller bags on Amazon and use them as treats. Champion Petfoods, which owns Arcana and Orijen, is working on its own and with others in the industry to try to determine the cause of DCM, but objected to the FDA's listing of brands. You wont find animal parts that are downright horrid or meat-by-products, nor will you find fillers that do not serve a purpose other than to bulk up the quantity. Summary: 90% of the ingredients in this freeze-dried dog food are high-quality animal ingredients that offer the benefits of a raw diet but is more convenient to use and eat. Tomato pomace is a by-product of tomato manufacturing. However, the biggest difference between these two dog food brands is that Orijen tends to use up to 15% more meat and animal-based ingredients in its formulas. Many people buy their food this way, and most of the time, it works perfectly fine. For example, fats help dogs produce prostaglandins, which reduce inflammation among many other significant functions. Both Carna4 and Orijen foods are made to be highly palatable. You will need to think about whether your furry friend requires wet or dry dog food and pay attention to whether they have an intolerance to corn, wheat, or soy. Best for: Adult small breed dogs at all life stages. Each of their formulas are meant to be in line with your pets ancestral diet, and also has healthy probiotics added into the mix to aid in digestion, support the immune system, and contribute to the overall wellbeing of your dog. But over the years that has changed in the past couple years to Kentucky. The best bang for your buck. In this article, we will be discussing the pros and cons and getting into details of each brand to find out which one is best for you and your pup, so read on if youd like to learn more. Their philosophy is to remain grain-free or use healthy ancient grains. What you feed your fur baby now will shape how healthy and happy they are in the future. According to the dry matter analysis for this food, it has 43.2 percent protein, 20.5 percent fat, 4.5 percent fiber, 23.9 percent carbohydrates, and 445 kcal/cup. I want to settle with one. The 65 lb lab will eat approximately $3.60 worth of food each day. PetCareRx: Wet or Dry Dog Food: Which is Better? Regarding carbohydrates, Orijen foods contain a maximum of 25 percent, and Arcana foods contain 25 to 30 percent. which needs at least 9.5 oz (270 g) of food a day. Aid in the development of the retina and visual cortex. TOTW and Kirkland are made by Diamond, which some consider the worst manufacture of dog food. For wet dog foods, Kirkland Signature typically provides a little more fat (about 3.11% more). Not only does Ollie have great ingredients, they have great savings too. Most vitamins can be found with a variety of plant-based sources such as leafy greens, orange vegetables such as carrots, pumpkin, and sweet potatoes, as well as in animal fat, tissue, and organ meat. A raw diet plays on that scenario in which an owner would feed their canine a diet consisting of raw meats. TheLabradorSite: Labrador Food and How to Feed a Labrador A Complete Guide, Businesswire: Champion Petfoods expands its biologically appropriate lineup. woofwhiskers.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. So, where do Acana and Orijen place? Many dog food brands pack their doggy meals full of artificial fillers in case you didnt know. Fromm Gold, our favorite formula from the brand, comes in at roughly $1.52/lb, while our #1 dog food Orijen costs about $3.84/lb for the Regional Red formula. The analysis must provide guaranteed minimum percentages of crude protein and crude fat, and maximum percentages of crude fiber and moisture. Next on our list is you guessed it Orijens sister company called ACANA. Again, depending on the size of your dog, this option can become quite expensive but a very healthy choice for your pup. By products are often the result of a meat protein source after the lean protein has been removed. Orijen is one of the legume-containing foods that seemed to be potentially associated with the development of dilated cardiomyopathy in dogs, leading to speculation about the potential that legumes might be blocking taurine metabolism. Kirkland dog food, led by Diamond Pet Foods, Inc., issued a recall because they couldn't be 100% certain that their dog food didn't contain salmonella contamination. If you DO switch to the 40 lb. The food is often considered part of a raw diet whereas the food is freeze-dried or frozen at the peak ripeness to preserve all flavor and essential vitamins as if you were feeding your dog a raw diet. Orijen is significantly higher in protein and meat content, and they use meats and other animal products that arent cheap. Taste of the Wild provides a number of grain-free formulas made with real roasted meat. Summary: Providing a good source of DHA and EPA through wild-caught fish, this grain-inclusive is made with fresh and raw ingredients to be easily digestible. Summary: This dry food delivers a diet rich in vitamins and minerals to help an older dogs body function correctly. Of the negative reviews, the most common complaint was that their dogs got sick after eating and they had to return the food. Acana and Orijen are excellent brands that care a lot about a dogs well-being, but there are less expensive brands that also use quality ingredients. This method can provide similar costs to wet or dry dog food but will definitely take more time out of your day to prepare a meal for your dog. Orijen doesnt sell canned wet food; instead, it sells freeze-dried food that produces wet food when rehydrated. Moreover, as the market gets flooded with an endless array of options, its getting harder to compare and choose between different products. Why buy organic dog food? This brand is more mainstream than Orijen, and so it is easier to find at retail stores, but this doesnt mean that theyll have every recipe. Kirkland is a different food. Zignature recipes contain incredibly unique meats as their main ingredient, with recipes including Kangaroo Formula, Guinea Fowl Formula, and Catfish Formula. Dry food, often referred to as kibble, proves to be a very cost-effective, low-maintenance choice for many dog owners. Puppies have very sensitive stomachs, and purchasing food that is not appropriate for their age or breed can cause them serious issues; diarrhea and constipation is not a pleasant thing to deal with, both for you and your puppy! Purina Dog Food. Merrick Backcountry Raw Infused Large Breed Adult and Horizon Complete Large Breed Adult dog food for large breeds. Related PostsOrijen Cat Food Reviewed: Pros, Cons, and Ingredient AnalysisBy Charles Grisham, Updated February 28, 2023 More specifically, Orijen guarantees at least 9.95% more protein. According to our records, Kirkland Signature has never been recalled. Calculate this over a whole month, and the pup has gone through 18.4 lbs (8.3 kg) of food. We will sum up the pros and cons quickly and take a deep dive into the brand as a whole. The 3 most popular offerings are: Purina Pro Plan, Purina ONE and Purina ONE Beyond. Kirkland Signature and Orijen both provide roughly the same amount of crude fiber. A 13 lb bag of Orijen dog food on Amazon is approximately $56 in total, which youll have to buy twice a month for a total of $112 per month. And to give you an idea of just how inclusive the brand is, we will be going over their special diet varieties that Orijin doesnt provide: If your dog has a sensitive stomach, Orijen is probably a write-off, and you are best trying Acanas singles recipes. Guaranteed Analysis: Wellness vs. Orijen According to AAFCO, all pet food labels must provide a guaranteed analysis of nutrient content. The main reason is that they produce their own product, in-house:amen:. No grain, no GMO, no potato, no filler period and its an 80% meat kibble. None of the brands have been recalled, but nearly all foods on the FDAs list of possible causes are grain-free foods. Ingredient Analysis: Chicken, turkey, turkey giblets, quail, and whole blue whiting are the first ingredients, and this offers excellent sources of protein, vitamins, and omega-3 fatty acids. The Penny Hoarder: Is Fancy Dog Food Worth the Cost? If you'd like to see individual product reviews, visit our Orijen Review Page or Kirkland Signature Review Page. You should consider treating your puppy to Victor Purpose Nutra Pro Dog and Puppy, Iams ProActive Health Smart Puppy, or Hills Science Diet Puppy Food to give them the best start in life. Go to: Top Best & Worst Dog Foods But honestly, price isn't really an issue. Orijen is a bit richer than Acana if your pup is sensitive to that kind of thing but you can't go wrong with either one. Four basic nutritional guarantees are required within dog food including: the minimum percentage of crude protein, the minimum percentage of crude fat, the maximum percentage of crude fiber, and the maximum percentage of moisture. Organic pea protein is produced by removing the starchy parts of peas. This begs the question, what plant-based ingredients is Acana using? Orijen offers a bigger range of flavors than Carna4 does, but Carna4 offers more exotic taste profiles, like goat. Keep in mind that the term crude is a term used to describe the measurement of each item (protein, fiber, fat) and does not describe the quality of the ingredients within the food (https://petfood.aafco.org/Nutritional-Labeling). But a quick glance at their formulas demonstrates that not only is joy missing -their motto is Joy in every bite - from the ingredients list, but so are many high-quality ingredients which they claim that their food includes. Lastly, the Orijen is expensive. Theres really not too many differences here. Both Orijen Dog Food and its sister company, Acana Dog Food, are made in Morinville, Alberta, Canada. Some talk about switching from other food brands, like Acana, to this, and their dogs, seemed to enjoy the food, but others brought up concerns about the food giving their older dogs diarrhea and causing them to vomit. This is definitely not the most expensive way you can feed a dog, not by a long shot. Orijen Dog Food uses wholeprey ingredients meaning the ingredients come from various parts of the animal sources of nutrition they use to make their products. What fruits and veggies are in it are there for a purpose and serve a nutritional value for your dog . Dry and Canned Dog Food. Youll often see multiple types of relatively pricey meats followed by various livers and even hearts. Cheap hot dogs that are using god-knows-what are also fit for human consumption, but it doesnt make it particularly great. Period. Perhaps Acanas biggest advantage over Orijin is the variety of recipes they provide. This ingredient is marked controversial because it may be derived from genetically modified rapeseed, which is associated with multiple adverse health affects. If premium is what youre after, Ziwi has it; however, premium obviously comes at a cost. Here is an overview of the different types of products and the specific formulas: Yes, Orijen Dog Food has a recall history. Even if the store sells Orijen, there is no guarantee they will have the recipe you feed your dog. CAT FOOD At All About Cats, we're obsessed with helping people make informed decisions about what they put in their cats' bowls. When choosing food for an older dog, you are going to need to be very particular in your choices. It is important to understand that common meats, such as beef, chicken, and pork are often produced in an industrial-like environment. Q: Will the food I choose for my dog have anything to do with my dogs breed? Look for what the food Does and Does Not Contain. Additional items such as food dyes or coloring are also controversial because they serve no benefit of being in the food in the first place. Orijen Dog Food is a pet food company owned by Champion Petfoods that specializes in making cat and dog treats as well as dog and cat food from what they call biologically appropriate food sources. Pea protein is produced by removing the starchy parts of peas. Whatever method you choose, ensure that is it well balanced between protein, fat, and carbohydrate content. You might be thinking that less meat means bad right away, but that doesnt tell the whole story. Orijen Dog Food Reviewed: Pros, Cons, and Ingredient Analysis. While organ meat is important, it should be consumed along with the lean protein muscle of the animal. They just wont be as good in concept. Some people might steer away from Purina because most of their products use poultry by-products and corn. Here is a short list of benefits provided by fats (not exhaustive): There is a relatively large difference between the fat content of Orijen and Kirkland Signature. For the sake of calculating numbers, lets say you have Americas most popular dog breed, a 60 lb (27 kg) Labrador Retriever, which needs at least 9.5 oz (270 g) of food a day. Review: Over 90% of the over 6,000 reviews on Amazon alone rate this food 4 or 5 stars. I feed a little TOTW every morning to my dog and he does fine on it. Review: Over 90% of reviews are 4 and 5-stars. So i got my puppy yesterday.He is 7 weeks old and full of life. Then at dinner he gets 1 1/2 cup of the Orijen with some water in it to slow him down and soften it up a bit. Flavor Options: Original; Exotic Meats; Beef. 2022 Veterinarian.org, LLC. In nature, a dog would have been hunting its prey and eating its kill raw. Orijen Dog Original Recipe Dry Dog Food ORIJEN Original dog food delivers a diet rich and varied in fresh, whole animal ingredients from free-run chicken and turkey, wild-caught fish, and cage-free eggs With 85% quality animal ingredients, ORIJEN nourishes dogs according to their natural, biological needs Fromm Gold, our favorite formula from the brand, comes in at roughly $1.52/lb, while our #1 dog food Orijen costs about $3.84/lb for the Regional Red formula. If you have a small dog, using Ziwi as an everyday food may be an option because they are one of the best producers of premium dog foods. You might run out of food unexpectedly or are getting low and need to run out and pick up their specific food. Additional meat-based protein sources for dogs can include game meats like venison and rabbit as well as non-traditional meats such as bison and even kangaroo. You can purchase Orijen pet foods from the following stores: You can purchase Kirkland Signature pet food products from these retailers: Canola Oil (Preserved With Mixed Tocopherols), Organic Canola Oil (Preserved With Mixed Tocopherols), (Costco) Super Premium Lamb, Rice & Vegetable Formula For Adult Dogs, (Costco) Super Premium Chicken, Rice & Vegetable Formula For Puppies, (Costco) Nature's Domain Turkey & Pea Stew For Dogs, (Costco) Nature's Domain Salmon Meal & Sweet Potato Recipe Cat Food, Fats help with the digestion and absorption of fat-soluble vitamins, Reduce inflammation associated with arthritis. In late 2019 the FDA also identified Orijen Pet Food as one of 16 companies that make products that may be linked to heart disease in pets. Many vets recommend Purina Pro Plan or Hills science diet because they are great for most dogs and wont break the bank. The best dog food isnt kibble. Zignature has a rather unique aspect to their brand: none of their dog food formulas contain chicken! The recognized life stages according to the AAFCO include gestation/lactation, growth, maintenance, and all life stages. My wife and I were discussing making a switch for our two year old lab's food. Get $50 Off your 1st Order with code WW50 or the coupon link below. Taste: Tie. Organs, cartilage, and bone are added to the food for their nutrient density so your puppy can grow into a happy and healthy dog. For instance, a 20-lb. Orijen Original is their most generally formulated and best dog food to suit the needs of the broadest range of canines. Both brands are equally good for their own reasons. Orijen is more expensive and uses more meat in its ingredients, while Acana is less expensive but uses less meat. - Easy Side by side Comparison. Charles Grisham, WriterLean about our Editorial GuidelineBy Charles Grisham 10 months ago. On the flip side, there are many dogs who thrive off of low carb, high protein diets, and Orijens foods are perfect for that. Formulated to support the dogs immune system, Freeze-dried, liver-infused, and small-sized kibble, More expensive compared to other formulas, Includes DHA and EPA from whole fish sources, Enriched with probiotics for easy digestion, Free-run poultry, wild-caught fish & whole eggs, Needs to be mixed with water before serving, Orijen Original Stew Recipe With Chicken, Turkey & Eggs, Orijen Chicken Recipe Stew With Shredded Chicken & Eggs, Orijen Beef Recipe Stew With Shredded Beef & Eggs, Orijen Regional Red Stew With Shredded Beef & Lamb, Orijen Tundra Stew Recipe With Shredded Beef, Duck & Lamb, Orijen High Protein Dog Biscuits Original, Orijen High Protein Dog Biscuits Regional Red, Orijen High Protein Dog Biscuits Fit & Trim. What's so important. Both foods are gently dehydrated or cooked in a way that allows them to maintain maximum palatability and nutrient density. Fruits such as apples and pears provide dogs with nutritional vitamins essential to their diets. Just like some of us suffer from wheat intolerances, so can our pets, so do not let them suffer and choose an appropriate dog food for them. A: The best dry dog food for your pup will highly depend on what your dogs specific needs are. Large ribeye steak cooked to perfection at a nice restaurant is priced higher than a burger because steak alone is more expensive as an ingredient than your average burger. Organic dog food has plenty of antioxidants that are beneficial to your pups health and digestive system. bags and priced according to bag size and the formula of the food. The dog could do better or worse, and you won't know. This premium kibble brand offers custom-tailored meal plans based on your dogs breed, weight, and activity levels. It is suitable for adult dogs and is sold in various sizes to suit most dogs needs. The primary ingredient in any of their food is animal-based, which means their products all contain high levels of high-quality animal protein. Summary: This dry food delivers high-quality protein using whole animal ingredients from free-run chicken and turkey, wild-caught salmon, and cage-free eggs. Look at the table for the brands fed to the studied . However, opponents claim that canola oil is typically produced with genetically modified rapeseed and that rapeseed oil has multiple adverse health affects. If youre looking for the best dog food, Orijen is it. Grain-inclusive formula with over 90% of premium animal ingredients for a versatile amino acid profile and strong muscles. The Halo Pet Foundation donates a minimum of % of salesfive times the national corporate giving averageto the Halo Pet Foundation and to provide food for shelter pets. Many of the same ones as Orijin, in fact. When feeding these items to dogs, it is crucial to remove all seeds and to cut fruit slices into small bite-size pieces for your pet. Overall, with the supplementation of vitamins and minerals, this is a very solid ingredient list. While providing a protein source in the food, it does not necessarily provide the most balanced and nutritional source of protein for the canine. are not safe ingredients to feed your dog long-term. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.