Ardmore, PA 19003. Without that key element, insurance coverage questions are left to regional decision boards, often comprised of insurance company representatives and public health officials who may harbor anti-trans beliefs they want to institutionalize. I think this will be my only update. Scan this QR code to download the app now, https://jezebel.com/when-surgeons-fail-their-trans-patients-1844774990. You can always catch up on Botched here!. According to Carlie and her mother, Dr. Rumer snapped at them in a phone call with Carlies mother: I remember hearing it clear as day, says Carlie, who could overhear the conversation. Dr. Kathy Rumer, DO / "The Butcher of Ardmore" / Rumer Gender Surgery This person seems to have botched life changing surgery for some of her patients and is now retaliating legally because these patients made their experiences known to warn other trans . Last time I saw her, she said she wanted to take some of my belly fat for a skin graft in my vagina, and it would take another year to heal. Dr. Kathy L. Rumer is a board-certified plastic and reconstructive surgeon in the Philadelphia tri-state area who has deep experience with gender reassignment surgery and a practice that is geared exclusively toward transgender patients. Copy and paste it, mirror it, etc. . According to the complaint, the defendants performed male-to-female gender reassignment surgery, a bilateral augmentation and related surgical procedures on Minto on July 12, 2016. We can beat Rumer through a war of attrition by denying her as many new patients as possible. Ive been warning people off Rumer as much as I can, says Ember Rose, a 28-year-old non-binary person from Boston. Schedule a Consultation Rumer Gender Surgery. She says she felt ignored and hastily cared for after a long and invasive surgery. One of the ways we create uniform standards has to be an open exchange of ideas, says Dr. Ting, of Mt. Kathy Rumer is an experienced plastic surgeon and surgical specialist who operates out of Ardmore, Pennsylvania. It's September and I still haven't had revision surgery. This Jezebel article also came out 8/19/2020, long after my May 2017 botched surgery: https://jezebel.com/when-surgeons-fail-their-trans-patients-1844774990 . Patients of Rumer often have to undergo stressful and costly revision surgeries with other doctors. When Surgeons Fail Their Trans Patients - Jezebel A compilation of screenshots, articles about Kathy Rumer have been gathered here. Like. Its a system that makes frank public discussion about surgical outcomes nearly impossible to have. These are . Scan this QR code to download the app now. We may earn a commission from links on this page. If you have any questions, or would like to setup a phone, Skype or in-person consultation with Dr. Rumer, please send us a message using the form below. While insurance coverage for GRS has benefited countless lives, an unintentional side effect has been what Dr. Marci Bowers, a San Francisco-based gender surgeon who has been practicing for three decades, refers to as a culture of permissiveness: As far as an insurance company goes, if the patient survived the operation, leaves the hospital in a prescribed amount of time, and doesnt die of some hideous complication or is not readmitted multiple times, she says, that is their measure of success. Providers like Dr. Rumer, she says, understand the industry and sign contracts to become preferred providers, effectively funnelling new patients into their practice based on these metrics. Sinai, to the stand. Audrina Minto, also known as Arturo Minto, filed a complaint July 2 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. Show them what happens when you mess with a community that is used to fighting for their existence on a daily basis. Dr. Kathy Rumer, DO is a Cosmetic, Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery Specialist in Drexel Hill, PA. Alexis Lake, Lake Therapy: This therapist serves the Lancaster area which has little to no resources for gender affirming care, not only is she a personal friend of Rumer but actively brags to her own clientele about how many people she refers to Rumer. Dr. Kathy L. Rumer is trusted by her patients for ethical, high quality care. Recent attempts to quantify the learning curve for vaginoplasty have indicated that 40 procedures need to be performed to truly learn the technique. Its their body and their right. But to make an informed choice about their bodies, he says, trans people would need more information about what happens when surgeries go awry. Many felt that going public about poor results may make it less likely for other surgeons to take on revisions, while official complaints to individual hospitals and state medical boards were lost in bureaucracy, misunderstood, or simply ignored. The suits described humiliation and severe psychological trauma as a result of Dr. Rumers work, and each originally demanded a jury trial but was eventually submitted for voluntary private arbitration. Sinai. UPDATE: a petition has been posted demanding Rumer's immediate resignation. alleging that the defendants did not have the appropriate expected from board certified plastic surgeons. Additionally, Rumers hair removal technique failed, leaving some hair growing just inside the labia, though not in the vaginal canal itself. A subreddit devoted to transgender issues pertaining to male-to-female or AMAB people. Most of her patients including the defendants in an ongoing case are low income an I SHOULD HAVE HAD THIS WHEN THE DOCTOR ORIGINALLY TOLD ME OVER A YEAR AGO. Whenever I deal with Dr. Rumer's office, I have to be the liaison for my insurance company and her office. Dr. Kathy L. Rumer is a board-certified plastic and reconstructive surgeon in the Philadelphia tri-state area who has deep experience with gender reassignment surgery and a practice that is geared exclusively toward transgender patients. She said it would be like starting from scratch again, as if it was the a brand new bottom-surgery. On June 12, a newly finalized HHS rule which eliminated gender identity non-discrimination protections within the Affordable Care Act recently garnered over 200,000 public comments. Most, understandably, declined to comment, but three who wished to remain anonymous had collectively seen more than 50 patients who had originally gone to Dr. Rumer for GRS since 2016. At this point, I can BARELY dilate. Specialties: Dr. Rumer, a board-certified plastic and reconstructive surgeon, is a renowned transgender surgical specialist. These patients experiences and their difficulty finding recourse arent about one doctor. I had bottom surgery with Dr. Kathy Rumer in May 2017. TRIGGER WARNINGS: BOTCHED MEDICAL PROBLEMS. According to the report, surgeons offering gender-affirming surgeries should undergo extensive training, including seminar, office, practical, and aftercare sessions, as well as ongoing continuing education. They went to all these conferences and stuff essentially to do marketing promotion of their work, says Green. RT @ShifterofShapes: Dr Kathy Rumer is another "sex reassignment surgeon" who botched countless patients and gave many colostomy bags along with other life long complications. She spent two days in the intensive care unit and five days total at the hospital. To try to fill the gap, people like Dr. Schechter and other doctors who specialize in gender-affirming care have come together to argue for a more standardized training system for hospitals looking to expand into the field. We now have urologists, gynecologists, and micro-surgeons of all kinds who are involved in genital reconstruction. 27 Mar 2023 05:58:12 Jezebel spoke to four others who say they experienced issues with surgeries performed by Dr. Rumer, ranging from allegations of poor post-operative care to construction of their vaginas that left them in significant pain or with vulvas that didnt look anatomically correct. The answer: It is up to us to hold Rumer and all of the people who protect her accountable. The Newsletter Bringing the Legal System to Light. In a time when the Trump administration threatens to roll back a decade of progress around trans access to insurance coverage and Medicaid reimbursement, some worry about anti-transition media crusaders leveraging trans medical horror stories into political opposition against transitioning itself, as Heyer did. Any association with this doctor deserves to be career ending and we need to make it a statement that anyone who aids and abets Rumer is to be heckled and shamed. Partners, caregivers, etc, with a legitimate interest in surgery may post if it's of clear benefit to a trans individual or the community. Can't keep records straight. PHILADELPHIA A patient is suing Dr. Kathy Rumer and Delaware Valley Aesthetics PLLC, which does business as Rumer Cosmetic Surgery, citing alleged medical negligence. Additionally, Simpson says that Dr. Rumer left excess tissue around the vaginal opening that made dilation extremely uncomfortable. Granted that even a serial butcher like Dr. Butcher Brown striked it lucky that he had a few happy patients who worshipped him? Marci however just so happens to have the power to drop Rumer from WPATH. Let him know how urgent this is in volume. For the people Jezebel spoke to who said they experienced poor surgical outcomes, there wasnt much opportunity to get answers. This must stop immediately. I'm sorry if this isn't the most well-written thing, or if there are gaps in my backstory. I have literally emailed and called Dr. Rumer's office over 100 times. (Like Alexis Lake, these guys are also deserving of some free publicity.) A team of doctors, none of whom had experience with a post-op vulva or vaginapost-op genitalia are slightly different from their cisgender counterpartsoperated on Carlie. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Dont feel comfortable putting public pressure on Rumer and her enablers and still want to help? I've gained much of that weight since then, but it's too fucking late now. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Dr. Kathy Rumer has 2 locations. Rumers litigiousness isnt unique among surgeons, and the environment can make it difficult for many trans people to find recourse, or warn others about bad surgical experiences. Carlie had just returned to Louisiana when she went to the movies with her girlfriend and had trouble sitting down comfortably. While most two-week-old post-op vulvas wont be pretty to look at, Carlie was alarmed when she found a large, thumb-sized piece of dead skin kind of floating out of it, she says. Give her some free publicity). And pursuing formal action against the surgeon isnt going to do anything to make up for what happened., I should have done more, she says, but I just had to move on with my life.. Call her up, (717) 575-3757 ask her why she is eagerly sending her trusting patients to a psychopath like Rumer. Kathy is having some hesitations before her double operation.. On Tuesday's episode of Botched, Dr. Paul Nassif agrees to repair patient Kathy's nose and perform a revision facelift after she . I meed much MORE urgent help now. Our sisters at Stonewall would have never accepted Rumer or her allies and neither should we. A few days later, Carlie and her mother say they heard from the doctor, who was on vacation and told Carlie she shouldnt be concerned. Its an institutional framework that doesnt fit the current challenges, says Green. Write to: The Honorable Jamie Raskin, Chairman, Subcommittee on Civil Rights and Civil Liberties 2242 Rayburn HOB, Washington, D.C 20515. Something like cardiac surgery or plastic surgery has., When I asked Green about the varying quality of standards in the current landscape, he told me it was because of our medical system: Its because of the decades of anti-trans bias that has existed, he said. Dr. Rumer is a leading aesthetic & reconstructive plastic surgeon who specializes in Gender Reassignment Surgery. "You can have permanent redness of the nose and, if the undermining of the soft tissue is too severe, you can have skin death. People will always make the choice of fast and cheap over good in some cases, he added more recently. Its been a fucking nightmare. She deleted her post to avoid more attention from anti-trans fanatics. She told me something, and then said she didn't say it. Cookie Notice Their entire staff was also emailed a dossier of Rumers non surface level atrocities and they remained completely quiet, theyre silence is violence. Now I can only get half-way to the first dot on my smallest purple dilator. Its who decides how the operating theater in the hospital is going to be used, what kind of surgeries they are going to do., They make those decisions and we have to just live with it, he said, and work around these things., None of that matters to Carlie, who has scuttled plans for other transition-related surgeries, like facial feminization, thanks to her experience with Dr. Rumer. Despite Dr. Rumers insistence that everything was fine Simpson developed necrosis of the vulva. Complaint. I had bottom surgery with Dr. Kathy Rumer in May 2017. Currently, I barely have a fucking vagina. COMPLAINT against DELAWARE VALLEY AESTHETICS, PLLC, KATHY L. RUMER ( Filing fee $ 400 receipt number 175427. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Rule 5: This sub is by and for trans people. Maybe they go and scrub in with one surgeon on one surgery and they say, Oh yeah, now I know how to do this. As one anonymous surgeon quoted in a 2017 survey put itsomeone is going to see someone with a reputable name; they learn for a week, and they start doing them. So who is responsible for allowing a monster like Rumer to continue? Kathy Hochul has called it quits after being blamed for driving her political . and our I live right near Manhattan. The most active members of the group left, says Danielle, including herself and a dozen others. Public pressure recently got Rumers attack dog lawyer to delete his youtube channel and potentially withdraw his candidacy for judge. Tune-in to the series premiere of Botched this Tuesday, June 24 at 9/8c! On the trans-focused message board Susans Place, one of the only centralized repositories of reviews for surgeons, warnings against libel abound, particularly in the Facial Feminization Surgery sub-forum. In finding a doctor to perform a surgery prospective patients like Carlie are largely on their own. For more information, please see our I'm not ok! The letter did say the office had reminded Dr. Rumer about the duties and requirements under state law and her local medical board. Audrina Minto, also known as Arturo Minto, filed a complaint July 2 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. We all want greater access for trans persons seeking surgery and we do our best to educate and to facilitate better outcomes, says Dr. Bowers, the San Francisco gender surgeon, but Dr. Dr Kathy Rumer is another "sex reassignment surgeon" who botched countless patients and gave many colostomy bags along with other life long complications. When Jezebel reached out to request an interview and offered a detailed summary of patient complaints in early 2020, an attorney wrote back suggesting we were conspiring with the unnamed author of a Blogspot site dedicated to exposing Dr. Rumer. BRUCE JENNER SURGERY HELL | National Enquirer Offices can vary widely when it comes to patient-to-doctor ratios and what kind of specialized training a surgeon receives. In late July, the presiding judge ordered Rumers legal team to show just cause to continue the case, considering the failure to allege the citizenship of the anonymous website owner since the complaint was filed in January. He only sees us as bags of cash. In addition to performing hundreds of gender-affirming procedures each year, Dr. Rumer also directs a 1-year . Imagine trying to run your surgical clinic and instead of getting calls for consultations you instead get angry calls regarding your continued support of a transphobic doctor. Kathy Rumer is a top tier butcher i've heard horror stories of vaginas falling out of bodies and exploding due to her butchery . I found new doctors thanks to Reddit. How many botched or dead patients one surgeon must have before we In the summer of 2018, the group of trans people who had surgery with Dr. Dugi in Portland met with OSHU to discuss how the hospital could provide more trauma-informed care for its trans patients. The step back, he says, is that some surgeons may not opt to train in the most rigorous environments: They dont join WPATH. Providing an Invaluable service to the trans community also means listening to the trans community, nothing for us, without us. Public Call to Action Against Dr. Kathy Rumer : r/MtF - Reddit People really have to go on gut feeling.. Kathy is history. That seems like her go-to word for every check-up: "beautiful." (Attachments: # 1 Case Management Track Form, # 2 Civil Cover Sheet, # 3 Designation Form) (jwl, ) (Entered: 03/20/2018) Main Doc ument. Her follow-up appointment, a week after the surgery, was administered by a nurse. U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania case number 2:18-cv-02800-PD, U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, Man trapped in chocolate tank for six hours argues his claims were properly pled, Volkswagen credit company says Lackawanna County seized vehicle that rightfully belongs to it, Sinking Spring woman settles injury suit with Lancaster School of Cosmetology, Pittsburgh man involved in tractor crash settles claims with manufacturer and Lowe's, Contractor seeks judgment on pleadings in construction inspector's wrongful termination lawsuit. Are You a Graphic Designer? When she posted about her experience with Dr. Rumer on message boards in an attempt to warn other potential patients, Carlies words were reprinted on anti-trans forums. But when Jezebel reached out to Dr. Rumer with a detailed list of questions and patient allegations, we heard back from a lawyer instead. In July 2018, I had minor surgery right in her office to remove some granulation tissue. A 2018 study by researchers at Harvard University and Johns Hopkins indicated that the number of trans-affirming surgeries showed significant growth between 2000 and 2014, with an increasing number of them paid for through private insurance or Medicaid. She told me that it's very rare for someone to develop granulation tissue like this a year after bottom surgery. He botched me and many others and killed a few. The organization serves as an active gatekeeper, laying out strict guidelines for which patients are allowed access to transition-related surgical procedures, but it does not expressly oversee the practices that perform them. I'm still bleeding. This is a great one to share. There are lots of great gender-affirming surgeons in New York; I'm not transmasc so I can't recommend anyone for top surgery, but absolutely do not go with Rumer if you don't want to be mutilated. It's a baby-sized vagina/wound. The Damage I got from Kathy Rumer - My Remorseful Suffering That took away my agency, changing around my story like that.. In 2017, Dr. Schechter co-wrote an article in the Journal of Sexual Medicine laying out some training minimums for prospective surgeons. As a result, only a handful of specialists in the U.S. even offered bottom surgery in the first place, catering to a narrow pool of patients who could actually afford the procedure. But the people who are not satisfied with their surgeries, at the hands of Dr. Rumer or others, have found it difficult to have their complaints meaningfully addressed. Just prior to publication, Dr. Rumer again declined to comment and through her attorney threatened to add Jezebel to her pending libel suit. Dr. Rumer, who has not treated the 65-year-old, added that "a botched rhinoplasty can lead to . Do not worry, direct action takes on many forms. I'm not a doctor by any means. Dr. I need help NOW NOW NOW NOW NOW. The two had spoken on Skype a few months before the surgery but never had an in-person pre-op appointment. I really didn't need this experience. AcheJ on Twitter: "RT @ShifterofShapes: Dr Kathy Rumer is another "sex On March 11, the surgeons attorney attempted to subpoena me based on an unfounded assumption that I was coordinating with this John or Jane Doe. These patients experiences and their difficulty finding recourse arent about one doctor. Heyer disputes the claim that he obtained the notes under false pretenses, telling Jezebel his Federalist article ended up resulting in blowback against his source, who in turn declined legal help to avoid further conflict. Intersex people who have related surgical interests may post. Her office is still open for business and she still performing surgeries for profit. The plaintiff requests a trial by jury and seeks damages of not less than $75,000, costs, pre-judgment and post judgment interest and other relief. (650) 570-2270. It was help that never materialized. Dr. Rumer began her career as an aerospace engineer. Dr. Kathy Rumer DO is a surgeon in eastern PA who has made a lucrative living performing GCS surgeries, the majority of which are rushed and have shoddy outcomes which leave the patients with lifelong injuries. Jezebel was unaware of this website when we began working on this story and all of the people interviewed said they had no prior knowledge of the blog. Often, patients rely completely on a surgeons self-reported data. Since 2007, she has had her own practice (Rumer Cosmetic Surgery), and since 2016, she has switched to focusing exclusively on transgender patients, offering a range of gender-affirming care such as vaginoplasty, facial feminization . Dr. Marci Bowers MD, the sitting president of WPATH: This doctor has not only been well aware of Rumer having done revisions to ex Rumer patients but has also been threatened with litigation at the hands of Rumer. There is no independent resource where patients can get data on a surgeons complication rate. A senior advisor to New York's governor, Kathy Hochul, quit on Sunday after reports emerged of him creating a toxic environment. In 2018, Dr. Rumer appeared in an NBC documentary about the transformation of a college student. Dr. Rumers attorney, Lance Rogers, wrote in a status report on July 31 that his office had additionally subpoenaed Google, CloudFlarean internet service providerand an unnamed domain registration site to gain access to the identity of the anonymous blogger, as well as retain the services of an expert in advanced investigative computer techniques. The case remains pending. Infections occur, tissue necrosis, dehiscences, those things occur with any surgery, he says. Dr. Kathy Rumer, DO. : Let us know and we will add them to this public list. I note that while you are a self-described freelance journalist, you utilize the pronoun the plural pronoun we (e.g. I need help! Bottom surgery for both transfeminine and transmasculine people is multidisciplinary in nature, requiring plastic surgical, urological, and gynecological experience. But Danielle says this whole thing just sabotaged a whole year of work within the Portland trans community, adding that while things didnt turn out ideally, she doesnt regret her surgery. Then we were supposed to book for February or March, but her office simply couldn't figure out how to handle insurance, and THEN they put me on a wait list to have surgery on July 17, 2019. Word of Mouth: In addition to putting pressure on Rumers allies, you can help put an end to Rumer's reign simply by just spreading the word. Stage a Picket: All of the individuals and organizations on the list have a physical place of business, nothing applies pressure more than a dozen people standing outside an office with a megaphone and signs and the first place that should be picketed is most definitely Rumers office in Ardmore. 215-563-0652 or 215-563-0658. https://linktr.ee/resignrumer There is also a subreddit /r/KathyRumer, Need to radicalize a friend who thinks its possible to beat Rumer via the legal game/system? If you want to put pressure on the heads of Mazzoni individually, working from this list might help. Share this post! Here is Mazzonis number, call them up and ask them why they wont denounce Rumer and continue to refer patients to her further endangering the community they claim to provide safe gender affirming care to. Rather than focusing on producing the best possible patient experience, the marketplace model encouraged these surgeons to become sales people for their own work. When a person in attendance confronted her about the images, she allegedly replied, you have a good memory, have a nice day. After a nine-month investigation, the medical board determined that the circumstances, in this case, do not permit formal prosecution, as per a response to the complaint shared with Jezebel. Constantly shifting insurance plans and laws governing insurers in the U.S. mean that trans people are often anxious to take on such procedures, fearing that while vetting a potential surgeon an insurance company might change its coverage rules. A week after the conversation with Dr. Rumer, Carlie says she visited a local gynecologist, who was alarmed and brought Carlie to Oschner Baptist Hospital in New Orleans for emergency surgery. Dr. Rumer was referring to World Professional Association for Transgender Health, or WPATH, the organization that sets out guidelines and best practices for trans-related health worldwide. Over the course of 2018, four former patients of the surgeons filed separate malpractice suits in Pennsylvanias Eastern District court. According to several studies, the industry average for those complications range between 10 percent and 64 percent. I am relieved that more people are becoming aware and it's extremely sad that there are more stories like mine. Dr. Rumer is an experienced surgeon: she has operated her own practice since 2007 and since 2016 has focused exclusively on trans patients, performing as many as 400 gender-affirming surgeries a year, including facial feminization surgery, breast augmentation, and GRS. That's my layperson understanding of this. Kathy Griffin has made a name for herself in the comedy industry and uses her celebrity encounters to make fans laugh during shows. Mar 20, 2018. Annoying the desk reps enough might actually get Mazzoni to finally speak up and say something about Rumer. Oh joy. 1. Without a set fellowship or apprenticeship guideline from WPATH or any other professional body, theres a broad range of standards for surgeries that patients will have to live with for the rest of their lives. This story has been updated to more accurately reflect the outcome of Hannah Simpsons surgery. If you think you can do better, why dont you just give her a vagina?. And speaking out after a traumatic experience, in a moment when so few are able to access care, can either be weaponized by anti-trans activists or interpreted by advocates as a step back. It kept accruing secretions and urine and got really smelly and I was scared of the thing for like the first year, they say, until I figured out there wasnt supposed to be hair there.. Dr. Schechter told Jezebel that hospital boards often require that a surgeon be certified by at least one of the 30 or so medical boards across the country and may have varying minimum training standards for potential surgeons. Rumers legal matters dont just end there, Dr. Kathy Rumer actually employed a Republican affiliated legal firm (with former Trump ties) to silence two of her low income trans patients from speaking out, and if this was not egregious enough, her lawyers were transphobic (forced a patient to disclose her deadname during a deposition) and ultimately got this girl to cave to a gag order under the threat of this patients genitals being up for public scrutiny in front of a juried trial which would be presided over by a Trump appointed anti-LGBTQ judge. Fear of expensive and time-consuming legal challenges based on patient testimonies are not unfounded: Dr. Rumer and her legal team directed letters to me questioning the integrity of your inquiry and article, declined to answer factual questions, and eventually served me a subpoena in an attempt to gain access to my reporting notes and sources. But according to Green, of WPATH, there are no medical boards that specifically certify individual surgeons for gender-related surgeries: I badgered the surgeons to get the societies, like the plastic surgery society, to try to figure out how to make this training part of the boards examination, so you could be board certified, he says.
Clarkson University Floor Plans,
Engaged Columns Egypt,
Articles K